This is certainly not the first course in which I’ve encountered Barthes' 'Death of the Author'. The dead author springs from the grave almost every semester to fight the auteur, armed with the claim that “writing is that neutral, composite, oblique space where our subject slips away, the negative where all identity is lost, starting with the very identity of the body of writing.”
I adore the gist of this particular standpoint of Barthes’, and I think it injects a healthy does of perspective into the critical understanding and close reading of a text. But it took some time to embrace the concept: I recall pointing out to my year 8 English teacher, with pained concerned (for the author was still very much alive at the time), that should we stumble upon some meaning that the author had zero intention of building into the text, then we'd be barking up the totally wrong tree. Eventually I've come to an understanding that a writer’s work develops a life of its own, that any meaning that can be read exists, and that ‘correct’ interpretation is a construct of educational evaluation and not a feature of the organic relationship between the text and reader.
Of course, when writing entails “the destruction of every voice, of every point of origin”, the author might operate as a useful compass that guides us in our initial steps through the text. But that person cannot be – nor should they have to be – the guardian of finite meaning for that text.
When we seek the explanation for a work “in the man or woman who produced it”, it’s like asking a mother to explain the behaviour of her fully independent adult son; an author gives birth to the text, at which point to text begins to breathe on its own (and, Barthes argues, leaves the author to die from the complications of childbirth).
Words develop their own agency the moment they flow from the pen. The text has the power to overtake and outlive the author, to become a Petri dish for unintended meaning, and reveal more than the author bargained for. Barthes refers to an understanding within ethnographic societies in which “the responsibility for a narrative is never assumed by a person but by a mediator, shaman or relator whose ‘performance’ – the mastery of the narrative code – may possible be admired by never his ‘genius’.” I agree that when we study a book, it is the biodynamic life of text itself, and not the person who wrote it, which deserves our attention.
As a side note, I suspect this theory is only meaningful when regarding ‘complete’ texts. The author might still hold the interpretive key to less creative forms of writing, such as shopping lists, letters, and essays.
Moreover, in tying this theory to Barthes comparison of writing and speaking, I wonder if this same agency is assumed by the spoken word, leaving the speaker’s mouth with the same abandon that written words do? I doubt the ‘Death of the Orator’ is as stable a theory, unless perhaps in the case of voice-overs and commercial commentary, where the speaker is hidden from view and the voice assumes an anonymous omnipresence.